Fall 2003 Library 101
Introduction to Information Resources

Syllabus | Schedule | Textbook | SCCC Library


EVALUATING INFORMATION SOURCES

 

General Evaluation Critieria

Evaluation tips for the Web

#1: PURPOSE

What is the author's goal? What is the purpose of the publication? To inform? To sell or advertise? To entertain?To persuade?

  • Web sites can be misleading in their stated or implied purpose.
  • Look carefully for hints that reveal the site's purpose.
  • Many sites are supported by advertising that might skew the content.

#2: AUTHORITY

Who is the author and what are his or her qualifications? Who is the publisher?
  • It may be difficult to determine authors & their qualifications
  • Publisher responsibility often not indicated
#3: ACCURACY Is the information accurate? How does it compare with other information?
  • Almost anyone can publish on the Web
  • Many Web resources not verified by editors and/or fact checkers
#4: OBJECTIVITY Is the information biased? Does it promote one perspective above others?
  • The Web sometimes functions as a virtual soapbox
  • Goals/aims of persons or groups are often absent or unclear

#5: CURRENCY
Is the information recent enough for your needs?
  • Dates are sometimes absent or inaccurate on Web pages
  • If included, a date may have various meanings: first created; placed on Web; last revised

#6: COVERAGE
Is the source complete enough for your needs? Is any information missing?
  • Often less in-depth than print or other media coverage
  • Web coverage may provide unique features not available elsewhere






 

This page is maintained by Lynn Kanne